The Caucus

Covering the people and issues shaping the Democratic Party.

500,000+ readers

The Newsletter · November 9, 2026

A Bigger Polling Miss Than 2016

Plus: Voters back taxing the rich, the races still uncalled, and new reader questions

Six days after the 2026 midterms, the clearest lesson may be that the Democrats' chances of riding a wave were significantly underrated.

First, we'll start with he pollsters. The final averages from Nate Silver's Silver Bulletin and RealClearPolitics both had Democrats winning the national House vote by about nine points. In reality, they're on track to win it by roughly 13. By early counts, that's a bigger miss than in 2016 or 2024 — when, rather infamously, the polls underestimated Republican strength.

Hindsight is 20/20. But a miss on this scale raises a lot of questions. And one that will be on a lot of Democrats' minds this week and in the years to come will be: What else about the voters are we underestimating?

Read the full edition →
Elias Isquith
Newsletter Writer
Caucus+ Ratings
Top 5

The Republican-held Senate seats Democrats are most likely to flip. Read the weekly rankings →

1North CarolinaRoy Cooper vs. Michael Whatley · openExpected D
2AlaskaMary Peltola vs. Dan SullivanToss up
3MaineTroy Jackson vs. Susan CollinsToss up
4OhioSherrod Brown vs. Jon Husted · specialToss up
5TexasJames Talarico vs. Ken PaxtonToss up
Updated WednesdaysFull board at Caucus+ →

Join 500,000+ readers

We’re an independent news outlet covering the campaigns, policies, organizations, and politicians in the fight for the future of the Democratic Party.

Subscribe for free. Or become a member.

01

The Latest

Reporting from the campaigns and the CapitolAll news →
02

Commentary

Opinion pieces about what matters nowAll commentary →
03

Q&A

Democratic newsmakers in their own wordsAll interviews →
04

2028

Tracking the Democratic presidential primaryMore →
05

Ratings

Where we see the race for Congress and 2028

Ranking the 9 GOP-Held Senate Seats Democrats Are Most Likely to Flip: Final Rankings

The House Districts Democrats Are Most Likely to Flip: Final Rankings

Ranking the 9 GOP-Held Senate Seats Democrats Are Most Likely to Flip: 1 Week Out

Rating Changes: 1 Week Out

The Top 25 House Districts Democrats Are Most Likely to Flip: 8 Days Out

Ranking the 9 GOP-Held Senate Seats Democrats Are Most Likely to Flip: 2 Weeks Out

All Ratings Reports →
Caucus+506 races · 4,540 candidates

House

Democrats need 218 of 435
221Before the toss ups
0 short of 218. 15 toss ups. Democrats hold 215 now.

Senate

Democrats need 51 of 100
47Before the toss ups
4 short of 51. 7 toss ups. Democrats hold 47 now.

Governor

50 offices, 36 on the ballot
27Before the toss ups
4 toss ups. Democrats hold 23 now.
Every race, rated nightlyFundraising, outside spending and weekly movement for all 506.
Open Caucus+
06

Previous Newsletters

What you missedAll editions →

Become a member

We are independent and reader funded. Subscribe for free or become a member to support our work and get access to all of our content. It's simple: The more members we have, the more coverage we can provide.

Subscribe for free. Or become a member.

Both plans include every post, the full ratings archive, and member-only reporting.

The Caucus

We're an independent news outlet covering the campaigns, policies, organizations, and politicians in the fight for the future of the Democratic Party. Not in terms of the constant horserace or as merely the responses to Republican attacks, but honest and fair reporting.

Jake Rakov
Co-Founder
Elias Isquith
Newsletter Writer
Kim Lyons
Reporter
Russell Payne
Reporter
Alex Rifaat
Reporter
Surina Venkat
Reporter
Nathalie Baptiste
Contributor
Samarth Gupta
Columnist
Aleigha Cavalier
Columnist
Join 500,000+ readers.Free SubscriptionBecome a member